Hmm…there are few oddities about the site, though.
The first lines quoted are taken from one of the three poems by Dickinson which include the word “Christmas” – though the lines are not quoted correctly (of course, they could come from some variation of the poem I’m not familiar with).
The site cites these lines:
And if my stocking hung too high,
Would it blur the Christmas glee,
That not a Santa Claus could reach
The altitude of me?
However, both the Johnson and Franklin editions of Dickinson’s poetry have the lines like this:
And would it blur the Christmas glee
My Stocking hang too high
For any Santa Claus to reach
The altitude of me –
Plus, the poem, “’Twas just this time, last year, I died,” was written from the perspective of one who had died – hence “The altitude of me.”
Following those four lines, the site includes two other poems by Dickinson, “The Savior must have been” and “Before the ice is in the pools” (another of Dickinson’s “Christmas” poems).
The really odd feature, though, is that the site concludes the post with a poem entitled “A Christmas Carol” (the first line is “Welcome, sweet Christmas, blest be the morn“) – but Dickinson did NOT write this poem.
But this gets even weirder. When I was trying to figure who did write the poem, I came across this site, HERE.
I tried to send a message to famouspoetsandpoems.com using their “Contact Us” link to let them know that Dickinson did NOT write that poem, but the feature malfunctioned.
Then, lo and behold, look what I found on the same site, HERE. It's the exact same poem, but this time it is attributed to William Topaz McGonagall -- and according to a list on Wikipedia, HERE, McGonagall did write the poem. And get this -- here's some info I found about the poet: "William McGonagall was a Scottish poet and public performer. He gained notoriety as an extremely bad poet who exhibited no recognition of, or concern for, his peers' opinions of his work." Hilarious! |